Please let me know if you
have different or new info, top tips and advice that
may help other
"dead ringers".
Is there really a fix for
the Ring of Death? I ask this as my repaired 360 ROD'ed
20 minutes after I got it out of its repair box. Microsoft
have admitted to the issue by extending the guarantee
for this error.
Some 360s come back with
extra
heatsinks in them and some don't ( someone posted today
in
another forum that theirs just got back without one).
A new 65nM chip is on the way that uses less power
and
pushes out less heat, but that's not going into consoles
for some time yet.
Microsoft has not been too
forthcoming about the exact nature of the problem, preferring
instead to take each case on its individual merits.
So all we can do is speculate. The only thing I can
be sure of is that the reliability issue is still not
sorted out.
Prevention is better than
cure, so make sure all sides of your 360 are well ventilated.
Putting the horizontal 360 up on blocks, to aid airflow
through the bottom vent is worth a try.
Plugging anything into the
360 to cool it can potentially make it hotter by using
the 360's power. High current USB devices should be
powered by phantom USB power supplies.
Laptop lap-fans might be
an idea - if you don't connect them to the 360.
The following repair methods
are
for information only. They are both dubious to me
because
they both require the console to overheat.
OPENING YOUR CONSOLE WILL
INVALIDATE ANY WARRANTY!
THE METHODS SUGGESTED
BELOW ARE POTENTIALLY DANGEROUS!
YOU
WOULD BE LIKELY TO DAMAGE YOUR
360
IF YOU TRY THEM.
PLEASE REFER ALL SERVICE
TO QUALIFIED SERVICE AGENTS.
The
X-Clamp Fix
This fix is particularly difficult
and will immediately invalidate
any warranty if attempted.
x360s have a "tamper-proof" construction that defends
well against the curious. It sounds tricky for even
the most competent electrical technician. There are
items that need to be "bent off" and this process
can easily destroy a motherboard, even in the hands
of an expert.
The
fix
also
suggests on removing the fans and overheating the
chips
for
a short period.
This
would rely on the thermal protection system kicking
in and is as dubious a practice as the towel trick,
in my opinion.
I'm including it on the site
as
it shows a valuable insight into the way 360s are
made
and the links show good pictures of the innards
of
a 360 and the "air tunnels" that provide cooling
from
the huge heatsink. Better to view those pictures
than
the innards of your own 360.
I thought it'd be worth posting an almost-comprehensive
rundown of how to fix - permanently - the problem of
the freezing 360. The method is incredibly simple, but
taking apart the console in the first place can be an
absolute bast.
This
fault, signified either by the three red rings of light
or by the occasional freezing of the image onscreen ten
minutes or so into play, is the product of a simple design
flaw that's got something to do with the motherboard
flexing as the console heats up. This causes the soldered
joints to break, and the GPU to... well, give up the
ghost.
So
after my third Xbox bricked itself last night I thought
I'd look up the 'x-clamp' fix, since someone had mentioned
it in another thread. Someone with too much time on his
hands going by the name of 'lawdawg' had posted a guide
with links, and so I decided to give it a try. It took
about two hours to do, and since then the 360 has been
running solidly, for roughly 6 hours, without fault (I
thought I'd break it in).
Mind
you, it was an excruciating couple of hours, and it can
get pretty bloody fiddly at times. But I was out of warranty
anyway, and I'd already decided MS's £85 repair
fee was completely outrageous. Anyway, here are the links,
since it seems the number of people on EG with borked
360s has become pretty massive.
-32
Metal washers: 5mm diameter
B&Q reference number: AVF-064968
-Thermal
Compound (for putting between the heat sinc and processor)
-T8
and T10 star screwdrivers
-Small
screwdriver / pointy tool (for prising open fastenings
on the case)
-Ordinary
screwdriver
The
issue is that the two X-clamps on the underside of the
motherboard have been designed to cheaply but effectively
fasten the heat sinc to the board, whilst simultaneously
forcing the GPU and CPU chips upwards and against the
sinc in order to encourage better heat dissipation. Unfortunately,
as the clamp is made of metal, it heats up and expands
a considerable amount; this, coupled with the fact that
it is shaped so that it bends inwards, means that the
board and chips end up being stressed and strained as
the 360 is used. This eventually leads to failing solder
tracks and in turn a garbled broken signal outputted
by your Xbox.
If
you try the methods linked above there are a few things
you ought to know first:
-There
is no drilling or soldering involved in this fix: you
are simply replacing the dodgy clamps with screws (which
hold the heat sincs securely in place without messing
up the chip itself).
-There
are only two clamps on the whole board, both of which
are found are on the underside. At first it looked like
the second heat sinc was resting on a third clamp - in
fact this is just part of its design, it has four feet.
You'll see when you take it off the chip.
-Taking
off the clamps can be difficult: lever each of the four
corners off with the small screwdriver, but try not to
slip and damage the board or any of the components.
-The
above-linked tutorial suggests cleaning the top of the
processor to remove the remaining thermal compound. In
my case hardly any was there in the first place, and
so I didn't bother. As long as you apply some more gunk
it shouldn't be an issue.
-Although
it may seem a bad idea to place metal washers against
the motherboard, they don't really make contact with
any important circuitry and so they work just as well
as nylon or fibre washers (besides, those are difficult
to find).
-The
method above may state otherwise, but there really isn't
any need to overheat the system deliberately after you've
done the modification. Mine works fine now without doing
this. If you do find that it is still giving you the
three red lights, then sort out the soldering by disconnecting
the fans and leaving it on for a couple of minutes.
This
is only worth doing if your warranty has run out, since
opening the thing voids it anyway. Over 400 people on
another site have reported complete fixes as a result
of this technique, and none of these have had problems
with their systems since then. One thing's for sure,
I'm never buying another Microsoft product again.
The
Towel Trick
This is not recommended. Some
visitors have requested I remove this from the web site
as it is not a valid or satisfactory means of repair.
Fatfish, from UKGamer.net said this:
"Might I make one suggestion
though - remove the video and mention of the towel
trick. Firstly, it's not a guaranteed fix, and even
if it does cure it, it's likely to only be temporary.
Secondly, it's not exactly the smartest idea in the
world - wrapping up electrical items in towels whilst
they're running in order to make them overheat............doesn't
sound a little risky to you at all? Plus, (IMO) mention
of half baked ideas like that just undermine the
overall aim - to provide an informative and helpful
site to aid those who will face the same issues over
the coming months/years.
If I didn't know better and I saw
that video, I'd immediately have doubts as to the
credibility of the other useful material and information
you've got on the site.
Thanks, I totally agree about the lunacy
of trying this. I'm still going to link to it because
I think people who have not heard about it need to have
enough information, so they don't waste their time searching
for some of the less objective accounts of this fix.
This involves wrapping the console in
a heavy towel for 40 minutes, whist turned on. It does
sound dubious to me and quite a fire hazard, but I've
heard reports that it can bring a console, once cooled
down, back to life. Do this at your own risk. It may
well further damage your console. Do not leave the room
and keep a bucket of sand handy, if you do decide to
use the trick."
I reckon If it does work (I've not tested
it), it does so by heating the innards of the xbox, so
much so that the cooked components, softened solder and
warped board move position under the heat so that connections
are re-established - temporarily. I'd question this as
a fix as there is no real exploration of the causes.
The box would be just as likely to pack up again, given
a slight tap.
Please do not try this trick at home.
It will not sort your 360 out in any long-term way and
is more likely to damage it further.
OPENING YOUR CONSOLE WILL
INVALIDATE ANY WARRANTY
THE METHODS SUGGESTED BELOW
ARE POTENTIALLY DANGEROUS
YOU WOULD BE LIKELY TO DAMAGE
YOUR 360 MORE IF YOU TRY THEM
PLEASE REFER ALL SERVICE
TO QUALIFIED SERVICE AGENTS